Page 1 sur 2

Alternate Nobody !!

MessagePosté: 26 Avr 2014, 11:41
de JTJMM
I'm confused! :? Does the original vinyl version of Nobody have an 8 second intro not found on any CD?

I've had this CD for about 10 years and NEVER listened to it.. yesterday i saw the thread in the multimedia section about the Nobody edit on the 1986 two-fer and i wanted to check if i had those edited versions on other CD versions of DRPTJ5.. i still haven't finished checking yet.. i need to check MOTD 5129, 3746351292 etc

the first one i checked was this version:

Image

CD CRB 561 on the German Charly Schallplatten GmbH label (1995)

Amazon ASIN: B000EIP59Y

it has an 8 second intro not on the other CD's. it times out at 2:25

Re: Alternate Nobody?

MessagePosté: 26 Avr 2014, 12:00
de JTJMM

Re: Alternate Nobody?

MessagePosté: 26 Avr 2014, 13:48
de mjdestiny
Merci pour l'info !!!! J'ai commandé le cd immédiatemment :D
Par contre je n'ai jamais eu le LP d'origine entre les mains donc je ne peux pas te dire si ces 8 secondes y étaient.

Re: Alternate Nobody?

MessagePosté: 26 Avr 2014, 13:57
de JTJMM
i'm going to listen to all the tracks later maybe there are other anomalies.

Re: Alternate Nobody?

MessagePosté: 26 Avr 2014, 15:39
de Roll
Merci pour cette info ! Sur les pressages américains (référence MOTD-5129 et 3746351292) figurent une version de 2:44. L'introduction est identique. Le fondu commence un peu plus tôt.


mjdestiny a écrit:Merci pour l'info !!!! J'ai commandé le cd immédiatemment :D
Par contre je n'ai jamais eu le LP d'origine entre les mains donc je ne peux pas te dire si ces 8 secondes y étaient.


Pourrais-tu mettre en ligne cette version quand tu recevras le CD ? J'aimerais l'écouter avant de le commander. :)

Re: Alternate Nobody?

MessagePosté: 26 Avr 2014, 18:47
de JTJMM
if this truly is the original vinyl version.. i'm shocked that Motown / Universal still have not issued the album on CD in it's entirety.. so even on the 2001 two-fer it is not complete.. it's been 20 years since i had the vinyls and i never played them that much so i just don't remember little things like this.

a couple of months ago i got this new Japanese pressing.. but it's still sealed and don't won't to open it.. :(

http://www.discogs.com/viewimages?release=5027418

Re: Alternate Nobody?

MessagePosté: 26 Avr 2014, 18:51
de JTJMM
what other compilations is Nobody on?

it's on First Hits

http://www.discogs.com/viewimages?release=4121903

Re: Alternate Nobody?

MessagePosté: 26 Avr 2014, 20:44
de mjdestiny
Roll a écrit:
Pourrais-tu mettre en ligne cette version quand tu recevras le CD ? J'aimerais l'écouter avant de le commander. :)

OK pas de problème ;)

Re: Alternate Nobody?

MessagePosté: 26 Avr 2014, 21:47
de JTJMM
**SPOILER ALERT **

i listened again.. i would label this as an alternate version musically..

it misses out the opening "nobody.. no.. nobody" chorus .. it has a new intro and then straight into the first "money in the bank.." verse.

i feel really embarrassed that i have had this CD sooo long and never noticed :oops: :oops: :oops:

i keep thinking my ears are playing tricks on me. :lol:

how strange that this is on a cheap compilation ??

i wonder what other gems are waiting to be discovered.

Re: Alternate Nobody?

MessagePosté: 11 Avr 2016, 16:30
de mjdestiny
JTJMM a écrit:what other compilations is Nobody on?

it's on First Hits

http://www.discogs.com/viewimages?release=4121903

J'ai commandé cette compilation aujourd'hui , je pense la recevoir d'ici une semaine .... on verra bien si elle contient quelques surprises !!!